Michelle Trachtenberg just isn't able to pick between Zac Efron and Chace Crawford in a dreamy-guy competition — which to us, seems crazy. (We pick both!)
Despite her inability to pick between those two heartthrobs, we do have to respect her taste in men: "That is a fantastic question!" the "17 Again" and "Gossip Girl" star told MTV News when asked to choose between the two, before throwing in a write-in candidate. "I'm going to go with Colin Firth. He is Dreamy McDreamy a lot!"