It's no surprise that Michael Jackson's album and song download sales have had incredible spikes in the days since his death. But despite the legacy of hits that Jackson has had, the top-selling track on iTunes has been "Man in the Mirror." While "Man in the Mirror" is not a bad song by any stretch of the imagination (and was a chart-topping single in 1988), why would people gravitate towards it and not "Thriller" or "Beat It" or "Rock With You"?
There are a number of valid theories, but pop musicology professor Stephen Pennington thinks the root is in the unresolved questions about Jackson's life. "The thing about 'Man in the Mirror' is that it isn't completely uplifting. It's got an uplifting sound to it, and it talks about making the world a better place, but we never get that better place," he explains. "It's incomplete and unresolved, just like his life."
Pennington is excited about the current conversation about Jackson's legacy. "If you look at the controlling forces about what is important in pop music, it's a lot of stuff from the '60s — the Beatles, Bob Dylan, Beach Boys. There are very few people of color, almost no women and not many contemporary artists. So people want to place him as important, but he's such a complicated person that you can't go with 'Thriller' or 'Heal the World,' because those are too far in either direction. So right now, 'Man in the Mirror' is the most logical song to sum up his legacy."





