
On Tuesday (August 24), the MTV Newsroom Blog wondered aloud if Katy Perry's just-released Teenage Dream was the best sophomore effort in the history of pop music. It's an excellent album, full of punchy pop tunes, lovely ballads and bratty kiss-offs, and it manages to eclipse Perry's debut One of the Boys in just about every way possible. But it faced stiff competition among the nine albums presented in the poll, including landmark releases by Madonna and Britney Spears as well as contemporary smashes by Lady Gaga and Justin Bieber. In the end, Spears' Oops! ... I Did It Again narrowly edged out Backstreet Boys' Millennium as the winner of the poll, but the highlight of the poll was the conversations that cropped up among the readers on that particular post.
There was an especially impressive showing by the fans of the Backstreet Boys (and that's not even including MTV News pop writer and Backstreet superfan Jocelyn Vena). Many of them followed the same sentiment as Nada, who wrote, "Backstreet Boys all the way! We all can't really deny that they got the best pop music in all history!" Commenter Jenn echoed that sentiment, writing, "Backstreet Boys all the way! Nothing will ever top Millennium!"
Though she only had enough votes to get her into third place, Lady Gaga still had some vocal defenders in the comments section. "While it is true that this album is nothing to overlook, The Fame Monster is the greatest album of all time (in pop music, there are some rock albums that outclass it)," commenter Noah wrote. "[Gaga] is twenty times Katy Perry. That being said, Katy is definitely a phenomenal artist." Another commenter named Lil_Monster also wrote lovingly of Gaga's second effort. "It's not the best album in the history of pop, but [Teenage Dream] is a very good album. It's got a very teen-summer feel to it, which is what I like. Definitely something to listen to while out with your friends. Gaga, for only an eight track album, is definitely something i can listen to over and over."
There was one particular album that seemed to pop up as an oversight, as several commenters noted that Kelly Clarkson's Breakaway should have been included in the poll. Clarkson's 2004 album was indeed a smash, containing the gigantic hits "Since U Been Gone" and the title track, which managed to eclipse her debut in just about every way. Had she been included, it's certain that she would have picked up more votes than New Kids on the Block.
One of the more surprising results of the poll was how few people voted for Madonna's Like a Virgin, which regularly gets mentioned in conversations about the best albums ever made. Reader chommy agreed. "How come like no one voted for Like a Virgin?" he wrote. "One of the most iconic albums of all time? There's a reason Madonna has been in the industry for over 20 years."
What did you think of the results of the poll, which saw Britney Spears and Backstreet Boys taking the top two spots? Let us know in the comments!






