
After months of contract-based turmoil and seemingly countless rumors, the producers of "American Idol" have finally made it official. The next season of the show — which is scheduled to begin airing in January 2011 and will represent the show's 10th go-round — will feature a judges' table that consists of Aerosmith frontman Steven Tyler and actress/pop sensation Jennifer Lopez (in addition to Randy Jackson, the only judge left from the show's first episode).
There has been turnover behind the judges' table before, but it has never been quite as dramatic as this. The show seemed to be humming along well as a trio before the introduction of Kara DioGuardi made the panel into a quartet. Then Paula Abdul exited, clearing the way for Ellen DeGeneres to fill in. But this season, neither DeGeneres nor DioGuardi will be returning, and that's on top of the fact that Simon Cowell — who has been the show's face and guiding hand since its inception — decided to bolt in favor of throwing his weight behind an American version of his hit British competition show "X Factor."
With all that upheaval, that leaves us with Jackson, Tyler and Lopez, all of whom bring distinct personalities to the show. But will they be able to provide enough different kinds of opinions to the table? And what will their chemistry be like? And most of all, who will assume the Cowell role of blunt, stern taskmaster?
All those questions will be answered in a few months, but at the moment, we can speculate plenty. Based solely on the idea of the new trio of judges, how do they match up against the other versions of the panel? Vote for your favorite combination below and let us know why you voted the way you did in the comments.




