"I'm reading so much baloney in everything. There was something in the press saying Jennifer Lopez is a diva. That woman is in no way a diva, they don't know what divas are if they think Jennifer Lopez is one. ... There is so much rubbish going on. My feeling is [the selection process] depends on the content of the panel, and the chemistry within it. I don't care if they're Romanian, as long as they fit in with the people around them, and we get a feeling that they know what they're talking about. All you want [in an 'Idol' judge] is somebody who's going to be honest with their decisions, not somebody who's going to say things to be nice. And why would a star, in truth, want to come on that show and say, 'You were crap tonight'? Because that star is going to be booed. ... So it's going to be really difficult. You just want honest people."

-Once and future "American Idol" producer Nigel Lythgoe, discussing various rumors surrounding who will be judges on the upcoming season of the show. In a conversation with Yahoo! Music after the finale of "So You Think You Can Dance," he talked about his goals for the show and what may be coming next. His comments about Lopez came following a story that she was out of the running because her "demands" had gotten to great.

Lythgoe wants fans of the show to have faith in him and to believe in the show's future. "Don't forget, when I started 'American Idol,' I brought over Simon Cowell, who no one had heard of, and a young man called Randy Jackson ... and Paula Abdul, who a lot of people had said, well, her career is over," he said. "And that was the start of a team that will be revered every time judges are spoken about. So it isn't just about what you've done in your career, it's about how you fit in with other people around you. And at the end of the day, it's about the contestants and their talent, and it's not about the judges."

Tags , ,

Katee Shean and Joshua AllenYesterday, we told you that "American Idol" executive producer Nigel Lythgoe is leaving the singing competition to focus on his other show, "So You Think You Can Dance." I only wonder why he didn't do it sooner. I've never been a fan of "AI," but I can't get enough of the summer dance show, which is airing its season-four finale tonight and tomorrow on Fox. Here are nine reasons why the dancers put the singers to shame.

No theme nights — A bad theme can ruin an entire episode. "SYTYCD" fans can rest assured that if (God forbid) "Music of the Night" pops up in a routine, it'll be the only Andrew Lloyd Webber song they hear all night.

Wider range of music — The dance show makes its share of musical missteps (using "AI" contestants' tracks in the name of cross promotion, allowing a certain choreographer to indulge in her baffling Celine Dion obsession, thinking that kids might better appreciate a foxtrot or jive if the Brian Setzer Orchestra is involved), but it also acknowledges artists too small for mainstream radio. Millions of people have heard tracks by Hot Chip, Junior Boys and Mirah thanks to routines on the show. On a related note, don't get me started on the way "Idol" turns a blind eye to hip-hop.
Read More...

Tags , , , , ,

Nigel LythgoeLongtime "American Idol" executive producer Nigel Lythgoe, the man who has been pulling the strings during the show's live broadcasts, has confirmed that he's leaving the program to focus on spreading the "So You Think You Can Dance" gospel around the world. He also said he is working on an unspecified new venture with fellow "Idol" producer and co-creator Simon Fuller. Then again, his departure comes after the show's uneven eighth season and amid suggestions that the highest-rated show on TV might be losing steam.

Read the full story here.

Do you think Lythgoe is leaving because "Idol" is on its way down? Tell us!

Tags ,

SPONSORS
AD:
©2012 Viacom International Inc. All Rights Reserved. MTV and all related titles and logos are trademarks of Viacom International Inc.